-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
Having done a survey on my site only one person was aware that the activity items were linked in this way, one other person remembers he did find this then forgot about it AND then started copying the starting text and using ctrl-F to find the comment on the post itself (which is what I and others on that site have been doing).
So, these links to…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
Having done a survey on my site only one person was aware that the activity items were linked in this way, one other person remembers he did find this then forgot about it AND then started copying the starting text and using ctrl-F to find the comment on the post itself (which is what I and others on that site have been doing).
So, these links to…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
Having done a survey on my site only one person was aware that the activity items were linked in this way, one other person remembers he did find this then forgot about it AND then started copying the starting text and using ctrl-F to find the comment on the post itself (which is what I and others on that site have been doing).
So, these links to…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
Having done a survey on my site only one person was aware that the activity items were linked in this way, one other person remembers he did find this then forgot about it AND then started copying the starting text and using ctrl-F to find the comment on the post itself (which is what I and others on that site have been doing).
So, these links to…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
Having done a survey on my site only one person was aware that the activity items were linked in this way, one other person remembers he did find this then forgot about it AND then started copying the starting text and using ctrl-F to find the comment on the post itself.
So, these links to the item are utterly and completely unintuitive to a…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
Having done a survey on my site only one person was aware that the activity items were linked in this way, one other person remembers he did find this then forgot about it AND then started copying the starting text and using ctrl-F to find the comment on the post itself.
So, these links to the item are utterly and completely unintuitive to a…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
I’ve modified the ticket there Hugo making the problem clear and that it’s an ‘enhancement’ rather than a bug . . .
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
AHH I see what you mean – that is completely unintuitive, none of the people in my site have ever spotted this . . .
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
activity entry for that comment does link directly to the post comment using the page anchor principle /#comment-one
It doesn’t do that for me either . . .
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
Hi Rosy, it’s a private invite site discussing aspects of the make up of reality although I’ve some public sites which don’t attract the same comment enthusiasm because it’s a very specialist area. Discussions of earth as a simulation: public discussions are here: http://www.soul-healer.com/simulation-argument/
It works the same way for me – you…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
Hi Rosy, it’s a private invite site discussing aspects of the make up of reality although I’ve some public sites which don’t attract the same comment enthusiasm because it’s a very specialist area. Discussions of earth as a simulation: public discussions are here: http://www.soul-healer.com/simulation-argument/
It works the same way for me – you…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
Hi Rosy, it’s a private invite site discussing aspects of the make up of reality although I’ve some public sites which don’t attract the same comment enthusiasm because it’s a very specialist area. Discussions of earth as a simulation: public discussions are here: http://www.soul-healer.com/simulation-argument/
It works the same way for me – you…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
Hi Rosy, it’s a private invite site discussing aspects of the make up of reality although I’ve some public sites which don’t attract the same comment enthusiasm because it’s a very specialist area. Discussions of earth as a simulation: public discussions are here: http://www.soul-healer.com/simulation-argument/
It works the same way for me – you…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
OK, I’ll do that Rosy, thanks
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
The commenting in activity option not only doesn’t change the link to the comments to where the comment is in the original blog post.
Comments are of ‘discussion’ AND often the comment being replied to is part of a long discussion which you might want to familiarize yourself with before replying to a comment to. Each of my pages averages 50…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
The commenting in activity option not only doesn’t change the link to the comments to where the comment is in the original blog post BUT even worse if you have this enabled the comments made to comments in the activity stream only get posted into the activity stream and not as a reply to the comment in the original post.
None of those plugins…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington replied to the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
The commenting in activity option not only doesn’t change the link to the comments to where the comment is in the original blog post BUT even worse if you have this enabled the comments made to comments in the activity stream only get posted into the activity stream and not as a reply to the comment in the original post.
None of those plugins…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington started the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
I’ve been using BP with WP on two installs through all versions for about 5 years.
In the BP activity stream we have comments from all posts and pages BUT the actual comment in the activity stream itself is not linked to the actual comment on the original post and page.
I’ve some posts and pages with 100’s of comments so just having a link…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington started the topic Comments in Activity Stream don't link to Comments in blogs Problem in the forum Requests & Feedback 9 years, 9 months ago
I’ve been using BP with WP on two installs through all versions for about 5 years.
In the BP activity stream we have comments from all posts and pages BUT the actual comment in the activity stream itself is not linked to the actual comment on the original post and page.
I’ve some posts and pages with 100’s of comments so just having a link…[Read more]
-
Clive Hetherington started the topic in the forum Ideas 9 years, 9 months ago
I’ve been using BP with WP on two installs through all versions for about 5 years.
Question: in BP activity we have comments from all posts and page BUT the actual comment in the activity stream itself is not linked to the actual comment on the original post and page. Is this how it is supposed to be?
I’ve some posts and pages with 100’s of…[Read more]
- Load More
@clivoo
Active 9 years, 9 months ago