[maikunari]

Just posting back with the solution in case it helps anyone else. This function will do it:
xprofile_get_field_data('Profile',$u_id);

In my case it’ll be:

<?php if ( xprofile_get_field_data( 'Profile', $user_ID ) ) : ?>
     <?php echo xprofile_get_field_data( 'Profile', $user_ID ); ?>
<?php endif; ?>

Thanks to chifliiiii on WordPress Answers and to @shanebp.

[maikunari]

@shanebp Thanks for the tip, that may be just what I need!

[maikunari]

@bphelp Thanks for the answer, but that doesn’t seem to be it 🙁

I tried <?php echo bp_member_profile_data( 'field=Profile:' ); ?> but no dice.
Also it seems to work fine without echoing it on members/members-loop.php.

It may be that the function only works inside the members loop, but I’m not sure?