Hi  @jeffm2008 – Thanks for the post!
I’ve just had a look at how Jetpack handles this. Unfortunately, it looks like it’s probably fundamentally incompatible with the way that BP’s top-level pages work. While BP does use WP’s page infrastructure in the Dashboard, it then tricks WP into thinking that BP pages are *not* in fact WP pages at the time that the sidebar is rendered. So Jetpack’s checks – technically, is_page() and get_the_ID() – are failing in the case of BP pages.
As an alternative, you might consider this plugin, which advertises support for BP content: https://wordpress.org/plugins/dynamic-widgets/
		
	 
	
	
	
 
		
			
	
	
		
		I appreciate you looking into it. Thank you for your help, I’ll check it out!