the WP Config is set correctly to my correct time zone which is EST.
I don’t see anything in the wp-config, and I’m not 100% sure what are your ‘blog posts’ and what aren’t. Can you link to a blog post? Or do you not have any?
Server time shows as 11:10am right now (Pacific) so that’s okay. (You can test yours by typing ‘date’ when logged in via SSH, but your profiles don’t show you changed the local timezone, so that wouldn’t do it).
You have a plugin called “wp-apply-timezone”
Is that something you ran after this problem started?
Rob, if you want to tell me your domain name, I can see if there’s anything on your server config that might do that. Are your posts similarly off-date or is it just the activity stream?