Thanks sooo much, that did the trick 🙂 I guess I was being too “elegant” ROFL. I made all pages related to BuddyPress parent and used WP Menu to organize my nav bar. All looks good now.
Thanks again!
Thanks for the quick reply Paul, I’ve included the domain affected so you can better check things out.
Regrettably, http://darthlama.com/groups/create also throws up the same 404 error message 🙁
What do you suggest next?