Update: I’ve tried actually backing up my data and deleting the Buddypress Plugin, yet the problem persists. Is there a way to clean out the DB of buddypress? The bad part about this issue is that the actual member page that I specify now has no security settings, and users that are not logged-in can view the page.
Good suggestions. I was hoping your “Customize” idea would work, but sadly the members item doesn’t appear there either. I have tried disabling BP and re-enabling, but it doesnt help. I thought about uninstalling but it warns that all the data will be deleted. That would be bad 🙂
Thanks @modemlooper, I tried changing the members page to something else, then changing it back but the “Members” item still does not appear in Appearance/Menus/Buddypress.