Skip to:
Content
Pages
Categories
Search
Top
Bottom

Whats with the big red backgrounds behind buddypress.org post links?distracting!


  • mcpeanut
    Participant

    @mcpeanut

    Hi i notice you have added a big red background behind each link now when browsing the posts on this forum, can i ask WHY? Because my first thought after using this forum for a while was NOOOOOOOOOOO! lol

    The reason i say this is because it really is a distraction from reading the topic titles themselves, i dont know why you did this but remove it already! hahahaha

Viewing 22 replies - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)

  • shanebp
    Moderator

    @shanebp

    If you’re talking about the sub-forum links on each topic on the main page – I have to agree.
    Of all things needing attention on this site, that wasn’t one of them, lol.
    But at least it’s a sign that things aren’t static.


    mcpeanut
    Participant

    @mcpeanut

    @shanebp yes indeed i was talking about them very links haha, man its driving me crazy as i spend most of my time browsing through the main page rather than in the actual sub forums as i like to read alot about everything, i keep getting distracted by the boldness of these links when trying to read the titles.


    John James Jacoby
    Keymaster

    @johnjamesjacoby

    The goal was to draw attention to the fact that individual forum categories even exist, as a fair amount of topics in our forums end up in the wrong place.

    Any suggestions how to emphasize individual forums without that emphasis being distracting to you?


    mcpeanut
    Participant

    @mcpeanut

    @johnjamesjacoby well if it was me personally i would either tone the color of red down slightly, but i think the better idea in this case may be to make the topic titles themselves a darker red to match more in with the background color of these links, so that the attention isnt taken from the categories (because putting a background behind them is enough of a statement anyhows) whilst staying in tune with the eye. (but you may not be happy with this if trying to keep in tune with the buddypress color)

    either way its down to you i can only suggest to you. as it stands in my opinion the boldness of the color behind the link sort of makes the topic titles less visible.

    Edit: After looking again maybe just try a few shades lighter so the eye sees it as the same color of the titles. or you could even lighten the color of the background and add a 1px border a darker red around it.


    shanebp
    Moderator

    @shanebp

    Remove both the background colors.
    Change the text color to black.

    In In bb-base/style-buddypress.css:

    #bbpress-forums p.bbp-topic-meta .bbp-topic-started-in a {
    	/* background-color: #be3631; */
    }

    In bb-base/style.css:

    #bbpress-forums p.bbp-topic-meta .bbp-topic-started-in a {
    	color: #000000;
    	padding: 2px 5px;
    	border-radius: 3px;
    	font-size: 10px;
    	font-weight: bold;
    }

    shanebp
    Moderator

    @shanebp

    Looks like so:
    new topic cat color


    mcpeanut
    Participant

    @mcpeanut

    maybe @shanebp is on the right track but i have an idea, seeing as you want to make it stand out more than just text do as shane said and add a 1px border #be3631; , so you are still makeing a statement!


    Bill
    Participant

    @chubbycrow

    Maybe just tone it down?
    http://cl.ly/image/1j0K3S3l3L0k


    Bill
    Participant

    @chubbycrow

    Or more of a compromise:

    http://cl.ly/image/3H3u3K2X3r2V


    danbp
    Moderator

    @danbp

    Love the last one @chubbycrow !

    Would see a smoothed version on closed topic ! Which looks really awfull actually.
    https://buddypress.org/support/page/20/

    #stars&stripes or #StarSpangledBanner ?
    We now have the stripes, where are the stars ? That’s the question… πŸ™‚


    peter-hamilton
    Participant

    @peter-hamilton

    It is awful, like being stung in the eyeball


    danbp
    Moderator

    @danbp

    @peter-hamilton, πŸ˜€

    I want something like this.


    peter-hamilton
    Participant

    @peter-hamilton

    lol, one of the best websites ever


    mcpeanut
    Participant

    @mcpeanut

    Ive been sat here rolling on the floor at that website @danbp, Its so bad its actually good!
    So funny if you refresh the page a different singer starts everytime lol, lets think about it really, how much time and effort he spent making it look that crazy! lol


    mcpeanut
    Participant

    @mcpeanut

    infact scrap my last comment about it being so bad its actually good! after browsing around it more its absolute genious! It is comedy gold! especially the video tutorial of how to use the website lmao.

    sorry we are going off topic now but couldnt help myself with @danbp posting that link, hahaha


    danbp
    Moderator

    @danbp

    @mcpeanut,

    laughing together is part of a user community. πŸ˜€
    Comparing a web 1.0/prehistorical best of site to our forum is off topic, of course, but demonstrate the existence of extremes in matter of design.
    To each his own. We must tolerate diversity… and so far, strong red category titles.

    Even if i personaly suspect a surreptitious advertising for a jamaΓ―can beer. πŸ˜‰


    modemlooper
    Moderator

    @modemlooper

    List each forum on the support page with a few (5?) recent topics

    [ How-to & Troubleshooting ]
    topic here
    topic here
    topic here
    topic here
    topic here

    [Creating & Extending]
    topic here
    topic here
    topic here
    topic here
    topic here


    shanebp
    Moderator

    @shanebp


    John James Jacoby
    Keymaster

    @johnjamesjacoby

    @modemlooper That’s not a bad idea. I’ll work towards that approach after 2.2 goes out today.


    Bill
    Participant

    @chubbycrow

    Just a couple further thoughts about this, since you guys are re-thinking it:

    If you really want people to get into the right sub-forum, why show a long list of topics in the first place? If they’re browsing, they’ll click an interesting-looking topic, and then end up posting their own question in whatever category they find themselves in (or append their question to an existing topic).

    On the other hand, if they arrive at /support with the intention to post a query without browsing first, it isn’t immediately obvious that a category must be chosen first in order to do that.

    An alternative:
    buddypress.org/support perhaps shows a couple/few sticky posts, but the main content is a modified version of @modemlooper’s ‘When Asking for Support’. I’m guessing few people actually open that link before posting. For clarity, it might even be sub-divided into its troubleshooting advice, and the installation-environment probes.

    I’d follow (or even precede) that with concise instructions on initiating a query by first selecting the relevant category from the sidebar list.

    If there is a desire to just have all posts sorted by most-recent, just link to such a page. The /support page as it stands now seems to be geared for browsing.


    The Barefoot Bookworm
    Participant

    @the-barefoot-bookworm

    Just my two cents, I think the color’s gorgeous (but then again, this shade of red is a personal favorite) and as a new user, it immediately draws my attention and helps me get oriented with the forums. It’s not distracting because I do need and appreciate big red signposts telling me where I am in the forums, etc, but maybe it could be made optional for users?


    mcpeanut
    Participant

    @mcpeanut

    Damn! Thats it staying then, Always listen to the woman, the woman is always right! πŸ™‚

    Haha @the-barefoot-bookworm only kidding πŸ™‚

Viewing 22 replies - 1 through 22 (of 22 total)
  • The topic ‘Whats with the big red backgrounds behind buddypress.org post links?distracting!’ is closed to new replies.
Skip to toolbar