Sorry I don’t remember, but keep in mind that wp-login and the password reset function of WordPress doesn’t get translated by WPML. The only way around is to use another login and password reset mechanism (that is compatible with WPML), most premium themes have that and certain plugins have it as well.
Thanks Paul. I spent a few hours tweaking every possible WPML setting and somehow it works now.
Because of the labour intensive testing process, I didn’t nail exactly what setting made it work.
