@mlakritz BuddyPress is compatible with nearly all WordPress themes. The few which are not fully compatible are those which have proprietary templating systems. Before continuing, change to Twenty Twelve theme and check if issue is resolved. If so, then it’s a theme issue. There are some solutions https://codex.buddypress.org/developer/theme-development/template-hierarchy/
You have other 404 problems too…
http://www.badgerakpsi.org/directory/user/26
So there is a larger problem with your page assignments or permalink structure or some custom theme code.
I am having the same problem. After I enter the group name and description and click submit the page goes to the next step but the form does not render.
I have tried deactivating all plugins, using the twenty fourteen theme, and tried dozens of other fixes people have tried, nothing works. Editing groups works fine, only creating a new group does not work. Once my group is created and I can navigate to the groups list, choose the group I just made and administer it fine.
Wordpress 3.8.1, bbPress 2.5.3, Rackspace virtual cloud hosting, dedicated server.
Please help!
UPDATE
I found out what the issue was. It was the varnish cache server which was installed and setup by default when you launch a new server on Rackspace. This caching server apparently breaks a lot of Buddypress. Warning to all! If anyone knows how to configure varnish to work properly with BUiddyPress let me know. Thanks.
I’m having the same issues. Not sure why BuddyPress would have such a problem with Varnish. What do they recommend instead?
