A reply to a notification email sends me to the admins address, not to the address of the sender of the original message. It causes misunderstandings, how could this be fixed?
WP version 4.7.2
BP version 2.7.4
You can’t reply to email notifications by default using the core plugin, but @r-a-y looks to have developed a plugin that does something like what you are looking for (it won’t send an email to the creator of the post, but it will create a response to the activity post back on the stream). You can find it here: https://github.com/r-a-y/bp-reply-by-email