Skip to:
Content
Pages
Categories
Search
Top
Bottom

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 19 replies - 51 through 69 (of 69 total)
  • In reply to: External Blogs

    @donnacha

    Participant

    @phlux0r

    We found that most members actually use the external blogs feature rather than create a new blog on the site…

    I guess that fact alone proves the thesis that being able to list their outside blogs is something users want :)

    BTW, beautiful site.

    In reply to: BP-FBConnect Plugin

    @donnacha

    Participant

    Ah, okay, SOLVED.

    I was logged out in that screenshot but Safari must have been holding a cookie identifying me a member all the same, resulting in the username field, password field and submit button appearing but not the Facebook button.

    When I finally realized what was happening, I tried with a different browser and, hooray!, the Facebook button was right there.

    So, now that I can see it, I would just like to say, officially, WOW, amazing feature, this is going to be fearsomely popular with users.

    In reply to: External Blogs

    @donnacha

    Participant

    @phlux0r

    Oh, for sure, don’t get me wrong, if you can have both as an option, excellent!

    My only concern is that all this impressive functionality may cause us to lose sight of the simplest form that recognition of external blogs could take: allowing the user to link to them, just a regular link, from their profile. In terms of need, that is a 10/10, because without it we will struggle to engage users. The other stuff is 10/10 in terms of want, but not having it will not necessarily impede a network’s initial momentum.

    If it can all be done, amazing, and I am very grateful for the work you are putting into this.

    In reply to: External Blogs

    @donnacha

    Participant

    @anointed

    Writers familiar with syndication are certainly going to require that, but I think what we all need to realize that even ordinary users, “civilians”, are now aware of the importance of linking to their other online points of presence, whether that be their Facebook/Digg/YouTube profile or even their own website.

    The idea that anyone is going to stumble across our BuddyPress sites, create a profile and start filling the blog we give them with content, without the standard “reward” of a link back to their “real” online home, is ridiculous.

    BuddyPress is a beautiful piece of work, but we need to start thinking about what drives actual usage when you don’t happen to be Facebook. We need those external blogs listed right next to native blogs.

    In reply to: External Blogs

    @donnacha

    Participant

    @phlux0r

    Conceptually, the content of external blogs not appearing in the activity streams is a good thing – a user visiting another user’s profile will be able to learn more about that user, including the latest content from their external blogs, but a user looking at the network’s front page will see only native activity. That actually makes a lot of sense.

    @donnacha

    Participant

    This issue has now also been raised by spisio in another thread: External Blogs

    If anyone else agrees that this is an important missing feature, please make your opinion known by posting in either thread.

    In reply to: Fans

    @donnacha

    Participant

    Of course, if anyone with actual coding skills agrees that this is an important feature, feel free to give it a go – I’ll be your fan forever :D

    In reply to: External Blogs

    @donnacha

    Participant

    @spisio

    Yeah, real world usage makes a big difference. BuddyPress 2.0 is going to be AWESOME :D

    In reply to: External Blogs

    @donnacha

    Participant

    @phlux0r

    Sounds really good.

    One useful option might be for the admin to be able to switch off the RSS feature and simply let users link to their external blogs; as JJJ mentioned in the other thread, some admins may have an issue with not being able to control the nature of incoming content, whereas a link out pretty much absolves responsibility.

    Personally, though, I like the idea of lively profiles buzzing with RSS imported content, and I think the profile owners will too.

    In reply to: BP-FBConnect Plugin

    @donnacha

    Participant

    @apeatfire

    This is what I’m seeing, logged out:

    Screenshot of testbp.org

    I see lots of Facebook avatars among the newest members, but am somehow missing the button itself.

    In reply to: Fans

    @donnacha

    Participant

    I’m not really a coder but I guess I’ll give it a shot.

    Thanks for the input.

    In reply to: External Blogs

    @donnacha

    Participant

    Incredibly, I don’t think any of the main developers see this as an important feature; I made a similar request about a week ago, after Andy’s announcement about the upcoming non-MU version of BuddyPress (which will, absolutely, need to be able to list external blogs) but, apart from a short, interesting discussion, no-one seemed to agree that it was a vital feature:

    Useful BP and non-MU BP feature: list outside blogs

    My conclusion was that this is one of those situations in which the people in a position to introduce a feature haven’t yet realized how important it is – it isn’t yet an itch they feel the need to scratch.

    But, yeah, it is one Hell of an omission, hopefully it will be introduced once the main guys have got their real-world BP communities running at full tilt and realize that most users will want to link to their main blogs.

    In reply to: BP-FBConnect Plugin

    @donnacha

    Participant

    This is no doubt a dumb question but I need to ask: where, exactly, is the Facebook login button/option/page?

    Both logged in and logged out, I have looked all over http://testbp.org/register and http://testbp.org/register but cannot spot it.

    In reply to: Fans

    @donnacha

    Participant

    Actually, forget #3, upgrading fans to friends if mutual, and forget #4, the whole idea of following the activity of people you become a fan of, Twitter-style (and, for that reason, I think it should be termed Fan, not Follow).

    All that would be needed is for a “Become Fan” button to appear under the “Add Friend” and “Send Message” buttons, leading to fans’ avatar appearing in the Fan section of the profile, directly under the Friends section.

    Would it be possible to simply copy the Friends plugin, stripping out all the unnecessary Friends functionality, retaining only what is needed to achieve the above?

    In reply to: Fans

    @donnacha

    Participant

    Thanks Burt and JJJ.

    So, logged-in user A visits the profile of user B and, under the “Add Friend” and “Send Message” buttons, there is a “Follow” button.

    Pressing this causes:

    1. User A’s avatar and name, linking to his profile, to appear in a section of User B’s profile called “Fans” or “Followers”.

    2. User B’s avatar and name, linking to his profile, to appear in a section of User A’s profile called “Following”

    3. Relationship is upgraded to Friends is user B ever happens to follow user A … OR request A’s friendship.

    (4. Possible feature for later implementation, but not a priority – The activities of users you follow appear in a special Twitter-style stream section of your home page).

    I am not a coder but, from your discussion, it seems it would be relatively straightforward, but would it put too much load on the server?

    I figure it would be roughly the same burden as the Friends feature, but possibly more because people may well end up with more Followers/Fans than Friends i.e. your profile might display 3 of 3 Friends but 5 of 30 Followers/Fans.

    @donnacha

    Participant

    Given that you are delaying the release of BP until site-wide plugins are introduced into MU, it might also be an idea to wait until the WP version is also ready.

    Although as anxious as anyone to see the official release, it occurs to me that any project only gets one shot at it’s 1.0 release and all the publicity that attends it. That one-off burst of attention can make all the difference to how much traction you gain in the long-run.

    IF BuddyPress jumps into the spotlight as an MU-only project, that’s obviously going to be of great interest to people already familiar with MU but the average blogger is going to scratch his head and not get much further than the fact that BuddyPress isn’t for “normal” WordPress. Disappointed, he will return to his extensive collection of porn and ignore all future mentions of BuddyPress.

    If, on the other hand, BuddyPress appears in the spotlight as a dual-release, with both a WP and an MU version, it will garner far more publicity, will be more obviously relevant to ordinary bloggers and will generally create a far larger splash, hopefully translating into greater momentum for the project.

    Just a thought :)

    @donnacha

    Participant

    What I had in mind was simple links, where Profile > My Blogs would be a page listing, first, My Blogs on <BuddyPress Name>, followed by My Blogs Elsewhere. They would be simple links that take you directly to the outside blog, losing the Buddy Bar.

    Using RSS to display actual content from those outside blogs on the BuddyPress site is an interesting thought, opens up a lot of possibilities but, as you say, would be tricky to police. It would also create duplicate content problems.

    The need being addressed here is not to pad the user profiles and activity streams with content generated elsewhere but, rather, to make the profiles more useful, having the humility to accept the fact that the most important information about someone may not be located on their profile page within our BuddyPress network but elsewhere, and allowing that user to indicate wherever it is he considers to be his online “home”. Yes, many visitors will exit via those links but, if they find this open approach useful, they are likely to return and use our BP network as a platform from which to explore more profiles – a classic open vs closed situation.

    @donnacha

    Participant

    Unfortunately, vBulletin decided that a vBulletin WPMU bridge was not in their commercial interests and locked the thread, despite 30 of their licensed users expressing an interest. The thread, http://www.vbulletin.org/forum/showthread.php?t=196906, remains readable but not new posts can be made and, therefore, can no longer be used to rally together all the vB users who would like to see it happen.

    I swapped a few emails back and forth with vB and they took the time to explain their position. I don’t agree but I guess I can understand their panic; WordPress is one of the few Open Source products that has wiped out commercial products in it’s sector, blogging, and they’re desperately worried that there is no longer that much difference between their $180 product and the free alternatives.

    There is, of course, nothing to stop any of you being a bit cheeky and starting your own threads on http://www.vbulletin.org/forum/, innocently asking why there isn’t a vBulletin WPMU bridge :)

    Personally, though, I’ve deciding to transition away from vB – I’ll be keeping my existing vB sites going but, for new projects, I don’t see the point of buying any more vB licenses.

    bbPress is pretty bad but I’m optimistic that they will improve over time, especially now that BuddyPress is advancing so quickly. I like the way in which, in BuddyPress, the forums are spread among the groups within the social network – it makes a lot of sense, sort of like wrapping each section of your forum in it’s own homepage, featuring the users who “hang out” in that section.

    @donnacha

    Participant

    Thanks JJJ and Daniel.

    Yes, the goal would be to have these outside blogs appear in the “Blogs” area of the user’s BP profile. I appreciate that this is a novel idea but, when you consider that we will all be tripping across dozens of BuddyPress sites every day, it is obvious that we will not be able to maintain active blogs in each of the communities we wish support or have a presence in. Being able to list our “real” blog on our profile should a standard feature of BuddyPress. Also, as I say, it’s going to be essential for the non-MU version of BP.

    Locking the content of those outside blogs into the BP site would be wrong, especially not using using hokey iFrames. Surely one of the best things about BuddyPress is that it smashes through the walled-garden mindset of the existing social networks and introduces a new age of openness; hopefully, people will find our BP sites useful and entertaining enough to want to stick around, even if we let our users’ profiles link to outside blogs. More importantly, we should honor our users’ participation in our BP sites by allowing them to create a real link to their real blog, that is only fair.

    As for WPMU Dev, thanks for alerting me to their plugin but, unfortunately, their pricing is currently geared towards institutional budgets, not the individuals that BP is now drawing into the MU world. Funnily enough, I posted about this on their site today and got a little conversation going:

    http://wpmu.org/all-wpmu-dev-premium-plugins-now-27/

    Please do jump in and add your voice to my call for them to revise their pricing to a level we can all afford.

Viewing 19 replies - 51 through 69 (of 69 total)
Skip to toolbar