Forum Replies Created
-
In reply to: “My Favorites” Plugin
I know it doesn’t match but i thought could be useful
Yeah, everyone knows how useful you are, how much you contribute to this community.
And, yes, your plugins can be adapted to create new functionality if a user has sufficient PHP skills.
The problem is that the vast majority of us don’t have your skills and, so, when a plugin is presented as the answer to a specific problem or need, users will presume it will do what the original poster asked for without needing to be rewritten.
Also, other developers who might otherwise decide to create a plugin to solve the problem, will see your post, presume that the problem has been solved and move on.
Sounds like a fantastic network, I can see how useful that feature would be in that context.
In reply to: “Report This” featureI see value to both “report this content” and “report this user” capabilities.
Why complicate it by having two distinct avenues when, clearly, users will be prompted to complain by a specific item?
It is absolutely vital to make life as easy as possible for your (presumably non-paid) moderators, so, the last thing you want is users getting flagged rather than a specific item, because that means having to go over the user’s entire output and make a serious of highly-subjective decisions about what is and is not acceptable.
Seriously, you don’t want that. keep it simple, keep it manageable.
In reply to: External BlogsExcellent, thanks Nicola!
In reply to: External BlogsSo, is this still happening?
In reply to: “Report This” featureI would need a “report this USER” plugin that allows other members to report an individual user to the admin…
No, it makes no sense to report the user, the specific item (whether it be a photo, wire comment, blog post, whatever) should be tagged so that moderators know exactly what the problem is and can decide whether action against the user is necessary.
Perhaps this could be combined with the Facebook/FriendFeed-style “Like” tag that egerrits has suggested in his Favourites Plugin? thread, and that betoverli has suggested in his “My Favorites” Plugin thread.
We could have small tiny links under each item, like Facebook, but saying:
like – comment – report
In reply to: “My Favorites” PluginYour Subscribe plugin sounds very useful if you want to track a particular blog’s activity, but it does not match betoverli’s request for a way to mark something as “liked” or to have that item then appear in the Favorites section of that user’s profile.
Betoverli does not want to receive alerts about new material, he wants a way to alert other people to items (posts, comments, photos etc) within the site that he has already seen and marked as a favorite.
Egerrit’s thread explains the idea more clearly and, again, your Subscribe plugin does not match the stated need. It would, though, be great to see a plugin that did.
In reply to: “My Favorites” PluginPost a link to your original thread, so that we can read your take on this idea.
In reply to: restricted joinI would like to see a way to hold new users in a moderation queue.
In reply to: “My Favorites” PluginThe problem is that it is very hard to keep track of topics in bbPress – if you make a good suggestion at the wrong time, it can get pushed off the “front page” before anyone has a chance to write a response and get a discussion going.
Also, because there is no email notification of replies, people tend to return less often than other types of forum, meaning that some people who might love your idea simply don’t visit the forum on the day you post it.
I think the trick is to keep an eye on topics as they emerge and, if someone posts an idea that chimes with one you have already posted, reply as I have above, linking to your original thread. I have successfully used this technique in the past to resuscitate threads that were initially ignored but ended up being lively discussions.
Great, thank you – I must start using the trunk, I have a feeling it will be quite a while before WPMU 2.7.1 is released, allowing BP to be released.
In reply to: “My Favorites” PluginSo, you mean something similar to the new Facebook “like” and “comment” features, borrowed from FriendFeed?
I agree that this would encourage more activity within the site.
As a first step towards this sort of interaction, however, I would like to see a way to become a “fan” (not friend) of a particular blogger within the site i.e. indicate your liking for a person’s entire output, rather than just individual items.
The Fans concept is discussed here: https://buddypress.org/forums/topic.php?id=1573
In reply to: “Report This” feature+1
In reply to: Facebook Connect…activated, and now?Not being able to see the Facebook button is a known bug, it’s not enough to simply logout because the plugin somehow considers you as still being logged in (cookie?) and refuses to appear, you need to use a different browser, one that you have never used to login to your BP site.
In reply to: FansI see this idea as part of a larger necessity–mainly being able to provide members with a way to more accurately describe their relationships
Once again, you nail it – I admire your ability to step back and describe the bigger picture. This is exactly what I am saying but your example of a BP network of emerging artists makes it much clearer than my example of a BP network of Open Source developers and their users.
Hopefully, we will see BP’s abilities and flexibility rapidly evolve because that is going to be, surely, it’s strength.
In reply to: FansSort of like following someone on Twitter, insofar as the number of followers someone has on Twitter is a good way to see how influential someone is.
In the first, simple incarnation of the Fans concept, however, I am NOT suggesting any sort of Twitter-style activity stream of the people you become a Fan of but that could be a more advanced feature at a later stage.
Right now, however, all I am suggesting is a way to indicate that you appreciate someone’s contribution to the community, like a sort of vote or thank you.
In reply to: FansThat sounds like a viable solution, thank you for all the great work you are doing.
In reply to: BP-FBConnect PluginYes. In particular, if anyone is still using Windows, it would be useful to know if this problem crops up with Internet Explorer.
Good points although I still think that if a user actually uses their blog, they will be aware of the difference between that and their wire. I mean, you have to consciously dip down into your blog, you are clearly no longer in the profile space.
“Anyone familiar with Twitter doesn’t need help becoming comfortable with what’s going on.”
Perhaps the comparison with Twitter is a little misleading, insofar as the visitor does not see the Twitter-style box, it is more a “QuickPress on steroids” for the blog owner.
It is not so much a question of making the blog owner comfortable, rather it is about that box sitting there as a call to action, an inducement to “Just Do It”. We all need a little encouragement sometimes – not having to dive into the dashboard to post will inevitably result in more posts.
“I think new users would relate more to a photo gallery type of layout than a twitter layout.”
Photo gallery layouts have the disadvantage of looking like a deflated balloon until the user actually uploads some photos. I suspect that, six months down the road, we are all going to be struggling with the problem of encouraging users to even make their first post, nevermind getting them to upload photos.
If getting people to use their blogs is going to be the problem, P2 could be the answer.
In reply to: BP-FBConnect PluginHmm, more of an issue than I realized.
Does anyone have any ideas on how to nail down the Facebook button so that it appears in all browsers?
Not being able to find the button is not a huge problem – people can simply spend an extra minute to sign up the usual way – but it is going to result in quite a few support emails for all of us if people are aware that Facebook login is an option but they can’t find the button.
Camino (Mac) and FireFox 3 (Mac) are fine, Safari 4 (Mac) had a problem.
In reply to: External BlogsIn case you hadn’t noticed, I posted another suggestion for a plugin that I believe would be immensely popular, a hack of the current Friends plugin to create a new, simpler form of relationship to be used in addition to Friends:
I think it would be a great addition to the plugins you provide at your BuddyPress Dev site.
In reply to: BP-FBConnect PluginI had the same problem but with Safari (mac), I don’t know if Andy noticed my posts about it.
As posted above, I eventually figured out that, although I was logged out, with the username field, password field and submit button all appearing to confirm that I was logged out, the facebook button was not appearing because it thought I was still logged in, probably because of a cookie setting still lingering from when I was logged in.
Simply try another browser to see what first-time visitors to your site will see.
In reply to: External BlogsAs an aside, it is ridiculous that blogs are not listed on the main page of profile but, instead, as hidden away in their own section.
If a user is actively using his native blog, or has active external blogs, they should be listed, under a heading titled Blogs, on the main page of the profile.
If a user created a blog upon sign-up but never does anything with it, the Blogs section should disappear from the main page of his profile.
In reply to: External BlogsAn important point is that the user’s external blogs be given the same prominence, possibly even appearing under the same section heading, as any native blogs they have created.
In reply to: External Blogs@Jeff – thanks for your detailed posts on the other thread. JJJ has now closed that thread with a post referring everyone here.
In reply to: External BlogsYes, sounds very good, thank you.