After some searching I found the Private Buddypress plugin.
That did the trick.
Hi, I’m trying to make my Buddypress members directory only viewable by logged-in users, but I’m not having much luck. I’d still like the rest of the site content (regular WordPress posts and pages) to still be visible to logged out users. I’ve been messing around with the information from this post , but I haven’t been […]
@switzern Not recently active