BuddyPress.org

this works great – how do you also exclude forum replies?

(… searching code …)

UPDATE: Well, I tried this code but it doesn’t work. Posting it here in case I’m on to something that somebody else can fix:

function bp_remove_forum_topic_post() { remove_action( ‘groups_new_forum_topic_post’, ‘groups_update_last_activity’, 10, 2 ); } add_action( ‘bp_init’, ‘bp_remove_forum_topic_post’ );

You can filter the activity stream on a certain page with something like this:

function bp_no_blog_comment_filter( $a, $activities ) {

global $bp;



/* Only run the filter on activity streams where you want blog comments filtered out. For example, the following will only filter them on the sitewide activity tab: */

if ( $bp->current_component != $bp->activity->slug )

return $activities;



/* Then filter out all the blog comments */

foreach( $activities->activities as $key => $activity ) {

if ( $activity->type == 'new_blog_comment' ) {

unset( $activities->activities[$key] );

$activities->total_activity_count = $activities->total_activity_count - 1;

$activities->activity_count = $activities->activity_count - 1;

}

}



/* Renumber the array keys to account for missing items */

$activities_new = array_values( $activities->activities );

$activities->activities = $activities_new;

return $activities;

}

add_action( 'bp_has_activities', 'bp_no_blog_comment_filter', 10, 2 );

Obviously you may want to tweak some of the details, but that’s the basic idea – the comments are still recorded to the stream, and still appear on the individual member streams.

Please don’t use my customization of Boone’s code above. It seems to be causing a failure of the Activity Stream, at least for me. Have not figured out why yet.

The achilles heel of @boonebgorges otherwise excellent approach is that you are essentially just removing items from the array, which causes activity stream atrophy. If you have a 20-item activity stream and 11 of those are blog comments, then you only have 9 items in the page before we get to “load more”, whereas you have a slow comment period, there may be 18 items on the page.

One a clean way to exclude blog post comments and/or forum replies from the main activity stream, but still preserve the activity stream length, would be by passing an additional WHERE != item to the database query. I couldn’t figure out a way to pass it, so as a proof-of-concept, I did this to exclude forum comments from the main page activity stream (on a BP install set up to display activity on the front page):

Go to Line 123 in bp-activity-classes.php:

$where_sql = 'WHERE ' . join( ' AND ', $where_conditions );



Add this line below it:

if ( $bp->current_component == "") { $where_sql .= " AND a.type != 'new_forum_post' "; }

This is just a proof-of-concept. I WOULD NOT take this approach for your site, because it will get overwritten when you upgrade your BP files.

Is anyone able to suggest a way to do this without messing with the BP core files?

It would be really nice if bp_has_activities (and bp_has_members, etc) had some sort of exclude or exclude_by argument. I might try writing a realistic patch for the core that would make something like this more than just a hack.

YES… PLEASE! I have made this exact point before. That would be awesome.

Also, not to litter these threads with circular references, but Jeff Sayre just said that his Privacy plugin component is going to allow fine-grained control over display of any activity stream. I think he’s anticipating having that ready in about 10 days or so.

But for tweakers, having the ability to directly interact with the streams via bp_has_activities() would be ideal, so if you’re able to do a core patch that allows exclude or exclude_by, I think it would be a huge help.

Old threads are never really the ‘Right Place’ they’re there as archive material to be read. Generally the correct form is to start a new post for your issue.

Have you not already asked this question a couple of times today in threads?

Please keep to this thread you started on the issue,
https://buddypress.org/community/groups/how-to-and-troubleshooting/forum/topic/editing-group-activity-stream/

if no response by the morning give the post a bump, in the meantime keep searching and reading old posts as the solution might well have been covered already.