BuddyPress.org

The admin email is the same as the domain name/URL already, I even went into the database to double check.

What you are saying is if the admin email ” This address is used for admin purposes, like new user notification.” after the @example.com doesn’t match the site URL like http://example.com it wont work right?

I believe we even installed from day one like that so I am not sure if that will help. I have a feeling I may need to try upgrading both WP and BP to figure this one out.