BuddyPress.org

the ‘my-members’ / ‘my members’ was a typo – it is the same WordPress page
<?php echo 'is_page()='.is_page().'<br>'; ?> – why are you doing this?

why, to demonstrate the issue. this is something you can do in 5 minutes to reproduce an issue I am seeing in a theme. Instead of pointing to the theme in question, I’ve shown the ‘bug’ in twentytwelve so anyone can reproduce it.