BuddyPress.org

Hi @adcurtisshawca,

are you running a wordpress multisite/network?

I see posts that say this is set in SETTINGS – BLOGS but I do not see such an option in my installation.

I think this refers to a multisite installation.
If you run a single site, maybe there’s some bug in the Theme My Login plugin. Disable it an try again. There are other plugins with similar functions.

Merry x-mas!