BuddyPress.org

@jamiewarren09 – ah, I just checked your profile and it seems I answered one thread before …

In any case, it has to do with your theme’s home.php and/or widgets you added in the home page’s widget areas. So you’re using the Church theme of studiopress. So open up home.php file and see if the member’s profile’s hardcoded into it, and if not, go to Appearance > Widgets and remove the possibly random member widget from home area.